Autumn Sale: 20% off almost everything until 15 NovemberSee the sale →
Wiki entry · 5 min read

Yorkshire Tea Decaf: Making It Taste Like the Original

Decaffeinated is not the same as caffeine free: the process removes most of the caffeine, and a small amount remains. What makes this box worth buying is the starting point, because a brisk, robust everyday blend survives decaffeination far better than a delicate one.

Published Curator-written, not crowdsourced
Yorkshire Tea Decaf: Making It Taste Like the Original, in summary: Yorkshire Tea Decaf is the everyday blend with most of the caffeine taken out, not all of it. Brew it four minutes instead of three, use a touch less milk, and it comes very close to the original mug.
Last reviewed by the teas.co.uk team in .

Decaffeinated is not the same as caffeine free: the process removes most of the caffeine, and a small amount remains. What makes this box worth buying is the starting point, because a brisk, robust everyday blend survives decaffeination far better than a delicate one.

Decaffeinated, not caffeine free

The label reads decaffeinated black tea, and that wording is precise. Decaffeination strips out most of the caffeine rather than every trace of it, so a little remains in each mug. If you need none at all, a herbal infusion is the straightforward choice; no decaf black tea, this one included, can promise zero.

No method yet takes caffeine out without carrying some flavour away with it, and the lighter aromatic compounds go first. That is why the starting blend matters. Everyday Yorkshire is robust enough to lose a little and still taste like itself: the briskness softens, while the malty depth holds up well, so the cup comes across as rounded instead of thin.

Four minutes, not three

The single most useful adjustment is time. Decaffeination changes the structure of the leaf, and what remains comes out more slowly, so four minutes on the decaf does roughly the job that three does on the caffeinated blend. Use freshly boiled water and resist pulling the bag early; in our view short brews are where decaf earns its thin reputation.

Milk needs a lighter hand too. The bags carry just over three grams each, the same fill as the eighty-bag box, so there is proper body, but a touch less milk than you would pour into the caffeinated version keeps the malt in charge. Add it with the bag already out, and watch the colour rather than pouring on autopilot.

The box for the one who had to stop

Plenty of homes have one tea drinker who has had to cut out caffeine and would simply like to keep drinking what everyone else drinks. That is the job this box does. Brewed with an extra minute, it sits alongside the ordinary Yorkshire mugs without anyone needing a different teapot, a different ritual or an apology.

Forty is the right size for a single decaf drinker in a family of four, where an eighty-bag box would still be half full months later. If more of the household switches, the Decaffeinated Yorkshire 160 box is the larger decaf option on our shelves. Keep the small box closed and dry so the last bags taste like the first.

The packs we stock

What the label says

The published ingredient list for Taylors of Harrogate Yorkshire Tea Decaf 40, 125g (barcode 615357252240) names none of the 14 major allergens. Check the current UK pack before purchase; formulations and allergen advice can change.

Ingredients, as published: Decaffeinated black tea.

Ingredient and nutrition data for this barcode: Open Food Facts (openfoodfacts.org), ODbL. The pack in your hands is the final word.

What to eat with it

Elsewhere in the Taylors of Harrogate range

The full range is on the Taylors of Harrogate brand page.

FAQ

Is Yorkshire Tea Decaf caffeine free? No. It is decaffeinated, which removes most of the caffeine but not every trace. For none at all, choose a herbal infusion.

Why does my decaf taste weak? It probably needs longer. Give it four minutes rather than three, because the remaining flavour comes out of decaffeinated leaf more slowly.

Does it taste different from normal Yorkshire Tea? Slightly softer. The briskness is the first thing to fade, but the malt holds up, so it stays recognisably Yorkshire.

Are the bags lighter than in the caffeinated box? No. Forty bags in 125g is just over three grams each, the same fill as the eighty-bag box.

How is the caffeine removed? Producers use different methods and they are not equal in flavour terms. If it matters to you, the current pack or the brand is the place to check.

Curator's note: Give it the extra minute and ease off the milk. Do those two things and whoever is drinking the decaf gets a mug that looks and tastes like everyone else's. Lee, teas.co.uk, Tunbridge Wells.

In short: Yorkshire Tea Decaf: Making It Taste Like the Original

Field Detail
Brand Taylors of Harrogate
Packs we stock 125g
Category Everyday Tea Bags
Allergens (as published) The published ingredient list for this barcode names none of the 14 major allergens.
Caffeine decaffeinated
Caffeine Decaffeinated, not caffeine free
Brew Four minutes
Milk A little less than usual

More from the tea wiki

Download as PDF

Got something to add? Logged-in customers can submit additions to the Tea Wiki, admin-approved, your name on the byline, plus reward points.

Sign in to contribute
Keep reading
Tea notes and stock updates

Useful tea notes, only when there is something to say.

Stock arrivals, buying notes and practical guidance from the catalogue. No filler, no daily noise, unsubscribe in one click.

By family

By moment

Brand of the monthHyson Seasonal taster packsHow the seasonal bundles work Tea of the Month ClubCurator-picked monthly box Find your tea60-second quiz 0 Basket £0.00
See all 906 products